
Garrett McCaffrey invited outspoken SwimNews.com reporter Craig Lord to participate in a discussion about what to do with tech-suit world records on my favorite SwimmingWorld.TV show: Split Time. The production allowed each participant ample time (over 22 minute run-time) to make their arguments in a mature, respectable manner. As noted in the comments on SwimmingWorld.TV, Craig Lord comes across entirely rational in his presentation of facts and the views he has on tech-suit world records.
The Screaming Viking, Shawn Klosterman, commented on the video:
“I was hoping to see him pound his armored fist on the table and exclaim “CRAIG LORD FEARS NO ONE!” Sometimes I like to imagine that he destroys two or three keyboards in the process of writing one article. He actually seems like a pretty rational guy.”
The speakers were in agreement on three main points: 1) That it was FINA’s “fault” that we are in the current predicament, 2) that the achievements of those athletes to set world records in then-legal suits should be honored in some way, and 3) that there should be only ONE current world record for each event.
Not surprising, however, there are some finer details that need to be worked out. Garrett and Craig stand firm in their views on several points. Particularly, Craig argues that records should be handled according to a precedent set in the 1950′s. Previously, FINA sought to standardize race conditions by only honoring world records set in a 50 meter pool.
In this way, none of the old records were taken away – however, a line was drawn in at the point the race conditions were changed and all new world records were set from that new point on (either from a FINA standard time, or from the last record set in now-legal conditions).
Garrett is an advocate for leaving the tech-suit records in place, because they set the records fairly under legal conditions, and force swimmers to catch up and aspire to faster times.
Craig ends the discussion with a call for transparency in the FINA decision-making process.
Watch the full video on SwimmingWorld.TV where you can also leave your comments on the discussion.